Oscars 2024 Nominations: The Most Shocking Snubs and Surprises


One of the one certainties of Oscar season is that voters will upend months of prognosticating from pundits by doing no matter they really feel like doing when the time involves fill out their ballots. As at all times, the bewildering snubs—no directing love for Greta Gerwig? Really?—had been accompanied by some extraordinarily nice surprises. Leonardo DiCaprio’s loss, you would possibly say, was Colman Domingo’s achieve. Here, VF weighs in on the issues that no person—or subsequent to no person—noticed coming.

Surprise: America Ferrera Stands Out in Barbie

Her efficiency was all-around nice, however that monologue! You know the one. Director Greta Gerwig informed VF that the impassioned “always/never” speech, which she co-wrote together with her co-parent Noah Baumach, “does not exist as it does without America. It’s hers by right, more than anyone else. That scene still really touches me. I see some of my friends’ teenage girls who don’t think they’re good enough, but they’re so beautiful and so smart and you just want them to know.” Ferrera has mentioned that Gerwig enlisted her to assist write the now-infamous monologue. “Some of what we talked about made it into the script. The line, ‘Always be grateful’ came out of that conversation with Greta,” Ferrera informed The New York Times. “She expounded on it adding, ‘But never forget that the system is rigged.’”

Snub: Margot Robbie Misses, as Does Barbie Below-the-Line

Tempering the joy of Ferrera’s deserved nod, Greta Gerwig’s comical cultural juggernaut missed out on enhancing, sound, and director, in addition to greatest actress for Margot Robbie (although she’s nominated as a producer for it in the most effective image class). Was it style bias, gender bias, or promotion fatigue? (And can the primary and final issues be defined by the center factor? Maybe …) Gerwig’s achievement in busting the field workplace with the very best grossing movie directed by a girl—$1.5 billion worldwide—didn’t translate right into a nomination for the director, who has three earlier nods: for steering Lady Bird (one other historic nod for a lady), for writing its unique screenplay, and for writing the tailored screenplay of Little Women). But all isn’t misplaced for the doll movie that launched a thousand assume items: Ryan Gosling earned an anticipated supporting nomination, songs by Billie Eilish and Mark Ronson did too, and Gerwig and her companion Baumbach—who tied the knot amid Barbie’s press push—had been acknowledged in tailored screenplay.

Surprise: Sterling Okay. Brown Snags a Supporting Slot for American Fiction

As Cliff Ellison, the brother reluctantly drawn again into the fold of his household after a tragedy, Brown brings each subversive vitality and relatable pathos to Cord Jefferson’s debut function. Cliff’s bought his personal shit occurring, however as soon as he exhibits up, we are able to’t get sufficient of him. Brown’s SAG nomination for greatest supporting actor—in addition to the forged’s well-merited ensemble nod—put him on the radar for extra awards love this season, and now the three-time Emmy winner has bought his first Oscar nomination, one among 5 for American Fiction.

Snub: Leo Loses Out as Killers of the Flower Moon Wilts—A Little

Lily Gladstone secured a greatest actress nomination, Martin Scorsese unsurprisingly bought a greatest director nod, and Killers discovered a spot in the most effective image class. But Leonardo DiCaprio’s failure to safe a nomination for greatest actor landed as each a shock and a snub, as did the movie’s miss for tailored screenplay, contemplating how a lot was manufactured from Scorsese and Eric Roth’s adaptation of David Grann’s 2017 bestselling historical past of the murders of Osage tribe members over their oil-rich Oklahoma land. Oscar race onlookers observed that DiCaprio leaned in to Gladstone’s marketing campaign, as a substitute of flogging himself, and he nonetheless notched a nomination for producing the film. Leo lives!

Snub: Bradley Cooper Gets No Love for Directing Maestro

Mr. Cooper has loads of issues to be thrilled about this morning: His labor of affection Maestro was nominated for seven Oscars, and his personal private tally now stands at a severely spectacular 12. Still, it’s baffling that the precise maestro behind Maestro didn’t get nominated for greatest director, simply as Gerwig’s imaginative and prescient for Barbie went unrecognized in the identical class. It could also be that voters knew that Maestro (and Barbie) would do exactly tremendous all in all, and determined to present the sting to the administrators of gripping smaller motion pictures, like Anatomy of a Fall and The Zone of Interest.  

Surprise: Colman Domingo Rises in Rustin

There are many causes to be glad about Colman Domingo’s greatest actor nomination: that it acknowledges an excellent actor’s nice efficiency (and a milestone: his first time as No. 1 on the decision sheet); that it’s going to convey extra consideration to the life and work of civil rights activist Bayard Rustin, an overtly homosexual man whose contributions to the motion had been marginalized due to his sexuality, however whose story is now being informed with an overtly homosexual actor within the function; and that it’s going to give us extra alternatives to get pleasure from Domingo’s stellar red-carpet recreation, which has been profitable hearts and minds all season. (Who else might pull off a mustard Valentino Haute Couture go well with with a gold coat?) In December, showing on VF’s Little Gold Men podcast, he mentioned this about Rustin: “Those rare times you get as an artist to really pour everything you have into it—all your skills and all the things you’ve been doing in the theater and television as a writer, as a director, as a producer, to create this film—it called on everything that I had.” Looks just like the Academy voters observed. (By the way in which, he’s terrific as Mister in The Color Purple too.)

Snub: Saltburn Gets Smoked

Emerald Fennell’s vicious satire of upper-class life (and working-class ambition?) was blanked throughout the board, lacking a semi-expected nod for greatest unique screenplay in addition to hoped-for nominations for actor Barry Keoghan and supporting actor Jacob Elordi that will have been realer within the minds of followers than they ever had been amongst Academy voters. Was this movie simply too misanthropic for basically sentimental voters, or was there simply an excessive amount of competitors on this surprisingly stacked 12 months? Everyone concerned may have loads of time to ponder the probabilities.

Surprise: The Teachers’ Lounge Is in Session

Ilker Çatak’s gripping movie a couple of German faculty shortly devolving into The Crucible didn’t appear to have a lot warmth going into the voting interval, however it grabbed a well-deserved nomination in the most effective worldwide movie class. Germany’s official Oscars entry follows a sixth-grade trainer performed with startling function and humanity by Leonie Benesch as she navigates a minefield of suspicions and defends her college students not simply from their friends however from lecturers and oldsters.

Snub: Time Runs Out for May December

Julianne Moore, Natalie Portman, and Charles Melton didn’t rank for May December, however a film revisiting (nonetheless artfully) the Mary Kay Letourneau and Vili Fualaau relationship—which began with Letourneau’s arrest for raping Fualaau when he was solely 12—was at all times gonna go down with some icky shivers. Imagine a movie with the genders reversed? You can’t. Wait, no—Stanley Kubrick’s Lolita. Which, come to consider it, was nominated for greatest tailored screenplay. Perhaps it was inevitable, then, that unique screenplay (written by Samy Burch) could be the one class the place Todd Haynes’s well-regarded movie ended up being acknowledged.

Snub: American Symphony Goes Silent

Matthew Heineman’s documentary is about artwork, love, life, and dying, for starters, however apparently Oscar voters wished…. extra? American Symphony tells the story of Jon Batiste’s quest to put in writing a symphony simply as he and his life companion, writer Suleika Jaouad, uncover that the latter’s most cancers has returned. Batiste informed VF that agreeing to such an unusually candid movie required a leap of religion: “It felt like it was much bigger than us. And even though it was more than we had bargained for going in, it felt as though this is what the spirit was leading us to do. It was a work of God that we had to complete to the end.”

Sad: Greta Lee Runs Out of Lives

Celine Song’s wildly spectacular debut, Past Lives, acquired two nominations, for greatest image and greatest unique screenplay. We would have beloved to see Lee’s exquisitely nuanced lead efficiency acknowledged as effectively. As Nora, a New York City playwright who reunites together with her childhood greatest buddy from Korea, Lee impeccably calibrates humor, affection, love, and remorse on the way in which to the movie’s cathartic emotional climax. Her absence right here isn’t technically a snub (this 12 months’s greatest actress class contains some legitimately fierce contenders), neither is it a shock, simply an event for a second of disappointment for what might need been. Which, come to consider it, is what Past Lives is all about.

Sad: Super Mario Bros. Gets Lemons, Not Lemonade

OK, possibly a film based mostly on a Nintendo recreation was by no means going to win greatest image (it’s not prefer it’s about one thing critical, like dolls!), however Jack Black’s virally fruitful “Peaches”? Hear it as soon as and also you’ll sing it, alongside along with your five-year-old, a billion occasions. A disappointing day for everybody who likes their nominations with a facet of enjoyment.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here