Popular Critic Takes a Nasty Dig at Marvel Latest ‘What If…?’ Character

The Disney+ sequence What If…? first premiered in 2021. It allowed followers to discover the multiverse and picture what would possibly occur if key moments within the MCU unfolded in another way. The thought was thrilling—however from the start; the present has been receiving very combined responses from viewers. Some followers liked it for its recent takes on acquainted characters and thrilling motion sequences, which had been among the many greatest within the MCU. Others, nevertheless, felt it leaned too closely into silliness and struggled to think about these occasions becoming into the bigger Marvel Universe.

Now, the present has returned for its third season, and the reactions are as divided as ever. This time, a brand new character has been launched within the sequence, and a well-liked critic simply referred to as it Marvel’s model of Harley Quinn—and never in a flattering means.

Did Marvel simply make its personal Harley Quinn?

Season 3 of What If…? featured a brand-new character named Byrdie. Naturally, this sparked curiosity amongst MCU buffs, lots of whom needed to know extra about her origins and powers. Grace Randolph, the creator and host of Beyond The Trailer, shared her unfiltered ideas on the character by way of X. “#Marvel has so many great characters,” she posted. “Why create a bad #HarleyQuinn ripoff?” Randolph, a Rotten Tomatoes-certified critic, particularly referred to as out Byrdie’s origin story, reacting with a blunt “YIKES.”

In the sequence, Byrdie was portrayed as a hybrid and the daughter of an alternate-reality model of Dr. Darcy Lewis and Howard the Duck. In this actuality, Darcy and Howard apparently received drunkenly married—an occasion proven in a first-season episode. Byrdie, nonetheless in her egg section, was rumored to wield immense cosmic powers, making her a goal. Nonetheless, Randolph was not the one one criticizing the third season.

Creator of X-Men ‘97, Beau DeMayo, did not hold back when it came to Marvel Studios’ third installment of What If…? both.

Beau DeMayo takes purpose at What If…? Season 3

Beau DeMayo lately took to X to ship his biting three-word What If…? evaluate– “yikes just yikes.” And he didn’t cease there. DeMayo hinted he might have achieved a greater job himself, cheekily including in a follow-up submit, “I’d watch extra to offer notes on the way it might’ve simply been achieved higher however I’ve some water to look at boil“. The present shouldn’t be performing effectively amongst followers, both. 

On Rotten Tomatoes, the season holds a good however not nice 75% on the Tomatometer, which is a noticeable dip from the primary two seasons’ cores of 89% and 90%. The viewers rating for Season 3 is even decrease, sitting at a not-so-great 54%. While there are nonetheless loads of optimistic opinions praising the creativity and enjoyable of the multiverse, many viewers really feel like this season simply doesn’t measure as much as the primary two.

What do you consider Grace Randolph’s evaluate? Let us know your ideas within the feedback under!