United Kingdom Berlioz, Bloch, Sibelius: Sheku Kanneh-Mason (cello), Philharmonia Orchestra / Jukka-Pekka Saraste (conductor). St David’s Hall, Cardiff, 25.2.2023. (PCG)
Berlioz – excerpts from Romeo and Juliet
Bloch – Schelomo
Sibelius – Symphony No. 1
You have at hand it to Sheku Kanneh-Mason: the person is a workaholic. Right after this efficiency of Bloch’s Schelomo in Cardiff, he was heading again to London for no fewer than 4 occasions in in the future with the Philharmonia in London, earlier than yet one more repeat efficiency in Canterbury the day after. While not fairly the “tour” that the Philharmonia had appeared to announce, it was nonetheless a formidable workload, particularly with a chunk that’s, if something, extra strenuous for the soloist than your common cello concerto.
At the time of Ernest Bloch’s demise in 1959, his popularity as a pioneering beacon of recent music stood excessive. But regardless of the discharge lately of wonderful recordings of his output, his star appears to have steadily waned ever since. Today, Schelomo is sort of the only illustration of his oeuvre carried out with any regularity. It is tough to see exactly why this has occurred. Maybe the important opinion that his music was too redolent of Hollywood movie epics rankled (though most of his early romantic output so condemned was written effectively earlier than that fashion had even change into established). It is a thriller why such parallels needs to be nonetheless the topic of suspicion – in an age which has welcomed the work of his contemporaries akin to Korngold again onto the live performance platform. Maybe there’s a exhausting core of modernism in his music which militates towards reputation; even the opening chords of Schelomo conflict with one another in a fashion which in every other arms would sound abrasive within the excessive, somewhat than as right here lushly luxurious.
Or perhaps cellists merely discover the intensive and demanding writing an excessive amount of like exhausting work. This Hebraic rhapsody doesn’t solely showcase them, however permits the huge orchestra its full head in locations. Be that as it could, we’re unlikely ever to come across a extra emotional and heartfelt response to the music than in a efficiency like this. Kanneh-Mason isn’t afraid to permit the music to soar romantically and to groan in abjection, and even to marginally bend the pitch within the closing bars to attain a way of oriental mysticism. His superb tone by no means will get drowned even by Bloch’s most strenuous passages of orchestration, and Jukka-Pekka Saraste didn’t pull any punches.
As an encore, Kanneh-Mason performed an association of Joseph Parry’s partsong Myfanwy, a tribute to Wales which introduced an instantaneous sigh of recognition from the viewers. Let me notice that this was his personal association of the tune, as I’ve realized from a assessment of a live performance in Boston, the place he had made his debut earlier this month. This goes to clarify the considerably disconcerting alteration to the ultimate line of the melody, which loses a bar, and the wholesale elimination of Parry’s authentic and generally bewildering harmonies. I needn’t say that the Cardiff viewers wallowed within the sheer great thing about the cellist’s supply of the lyrical line, and roared their approval on the finish.
After the interval, Saraste gave a efficiency of the Sibelius First Symphony. It was dramatic within the excessive, and bathed in superb mild all through – no trace of the Finnish gloom that was to hang-out the later symphonies. The gamers responded with headlong enthusiasm to Saraste’s whirlwind tempi, and even the growling basses and brasses had a decidedly defiant edge to their taking part in. Sadly, the Cardiff viewers had imported their customary inflow of colds and coughs, and that disturbed the serene great thing about Mark van der Wiel’s opening clarinet solo (though I’ve heard worse in pre-pandemic days).
Before Schelomo, Saraste and the orchestra carried out what had been described as “excerpts from Romeo and Juliet”. It isn’t unusual now to provide the purely orchestral actions of Berlioz’s prolonged “dramatic symphony” shorn of their vocal parts, consisting of 5 sections of rating. But what we had right here had been simply two: the love scene (with out the atmospheric choral opening) after which, out of dramatic order, Romeo’s solo scene which ends up in the Capulets’ ball. This sequence was fairly pairing, however the impact was largely misplaced as a result of the author of the programme notice had clearly not been knowledgeable of what the orchestra was really going to play. There had been no titles for the sections, no clarification of what the music was depicting – worst of all, of a protracted and awkward silent pause on the finish. At least some in viewers had been clearly anticipating the “Queen Mab scherzo” to which Gavin Plumley had really referred within the booklet notes. In the circumstances, too, the efficiency lacked the dramatic involvement so evident elsewhere. The balcony scene depends for its environment on the exchanges between the lovers. Here it appeared purely melodic somewhat than anxious. And the distant however dramatically necessary rustling tambourine throughout Roméo seul (which heralds the graduation of the ball) was virtually inaudible. The return of Romeo’s theme on the climax of the leisure, when he first sees Juliet, was blared out by the trombones to an extent that almost obliterated the dance rhythms within the strings. This ought to have been an thrilling starting to the live performance, however it somewhat missed hearth.
I used to be happy to notice that viewers attendances at St David’s Hall maintain the elevated numbers evident because the finish of pandemic restrictions. And that regardless of the unlucky coincidence of a pivotal Wales-English rugby match the identical night simply down the highway; that meant not solely the disruption of public transport but additionally the acute shortage of parking. I spoke to 1 couple who had made some extent of driving into the town early within the morning particularly so as to attend this live performance. Their dedication was rewarded with some superlative music making. They don’t appear to have been the one members of the viewers who had gone to such lengths: the bar earlier than the live performance was crowded with those that had deserted their vehicles and travelled in by prepare and bus a full hour earlier than the efficiency started.
Paul Corfield Godfrey