‘My Animal’ Review: A Moody, Trippy Queer Werewolf Romance Is Limited, But A Remarkably Assured Debut [Sundance]

Like most youngsters, Heather (non-binary actor Bobbi Salvör Menuez), a social misfit who lives in a rural city in northern Canada, has a strict midnight curfew to stick to. But not like different youngsters, staying out for longer has a way more harmful impact on her. We be taught that within the opening scene of “My Animal,” — the digital camera trains its gaze on the red-headed Heather sitting in a darkish room watching a werewolf film whereas slowly remodeling right into a werewolf herself, her eyes glowing and her breath heaving. It’s a situation that director Jacqueline Castel suggests Heather inherited from her father, Henry (Stephen McHattie) — and though the movie doesn’t interpret her assaults as a household curse, it nonetheless complicates Heather’s already current emotions of alienation. 

READ MORE: 25 Most Anticipated Films At The Sundance Film Festival

Even earlier than she stumbled upon her secret werewolf id, Heather had lived out a lifetime of loneliness on the fringes; an ungainly red-haired social outcast habituated to suppressing sides of her id as an alternative of sharing it — and even celebrating it. A friendless introvert who works on the neighborhood ice rink, Heather’s one dream is to play for the all-male hockey workforce. But as luck would have it, the coach prefers her youthful brothers over her within the workforce. 

As we quickly be taught, Heather’s intense emotions of exclusion aren’t solely triggered by her furry transformation and even household dysfunctionalism. Instead, it’s rooted squarely in her repressed lesbian sexuality. Heather’s conflicted sense of self is challenged when she meets Jonny (a luminous Amandla Stenberg), a beautiful figure-skater on the grocery retailer. It’s simple to inform that Heather is immediately enamored by Jonny, and it doesn’t assist that their meet-cute is lower quick when Jonny abruptly takes off with Rick, her macho boyfriend (Cory Lipman).

That alone situates the androgynous Heather as an unlikely werewolf heroine, making her story that rather more fascinating and elevating “My Animal” from a normal coming-of-age drama. In her remarkably assured function debut, Castel sensitively amplifies Heather’s outsider standing in “My Animal” by mixing Heather’s twin identities within the plot. The story at hand is two-fold — an evocative character portrait of a younger girl who struggles to observe her ardour in a male-dominated sport whereas looking for love and acceptance in a world the place heterosexuality is the norm. Indeed, deciding to function a queer protagonist because the lead of a werewolf drama is a intelligent contact of hand, provided that it provides thematic weight to refashioning a narrative about queer past love. 

The unhurried tempo of “My Animal” positive factors from Castel’s hyper-stylistic thrives. Working with cinematographer Bryn McCashin, the filmmaker depends on a cold palette to craft the movie as a rewarding temper piece. For a lot of the movie, the filmmaker employs the colour purple to articulate Heather’s interior anxieties, a call that provides a extra ominous edge to “My Animal.” Still, the pleasures of the swaying digital camera are finest evident in scenes that function Heather and Jonny in the identical body — the digital camera frames them in ingenious methods, placing them at a take away from the remainder of the world as if to underline the significance of the world they uncover when they’re in one another’s firm.

That’s seen in one of many movie’s finest scenes that seize Heather and Jonny making out with one another in a dimly-lit toilet with an urgency that doesn’t solely really feel revelatory but additionally essential. The warmth that this scene generates is pushed partly because of the effectivity of McCashin’s digital camera, in its capacity to convey surging starvation and satiation with a indifferent eye. The restraint that Castel exhibits in her rendering of this queer romance is masterfully contrasted by the showy renditions of Heather’s transformation and sexual goals as if figuring out precisely when to tease the viewers and when to drag again. In reality, the scorching chemistry that Menuez and Stenberg effortlessly conjure up can also be value noting, provided that “My Animal” is at its strongest when it has each of them onscreen. 

Still, for a movie with such a particular, trippy character, “My Animal” finally ends up being unbelievably conservative and vapid in its plotting — the narrative doesn’t appear curious about ever climaxing. Both Heather and Jonny look like largely underdeveloped characters, which takes away primarily from the effectiveness of the lead performances. The understanding of how Heather’s strained familial relationships form her id is likewise restricted. Even extra baffling is the superficial commentary that plagues Jae Matthews’ stilted screenplay. That means “My Animal” squanders the possibility to make use of Heather’s animal transformation as a metaphor for her budding libido in thrilling, intriguing methods. Even Jonny’s conflicted emotions about her personal sexuality is vaguely rendered, leaving the movie with an all-around vacancy. In its incapacity to promote its narrative stakes, “My Animal” falls quick regardless of its promising potential. [C+]

Follow together with all our protection of the 2023 Sundance Film Festival.