Starting with early frames that seize one very chilly East Coast winter with cozy grain, director William Oldroyd’s beautiful but thin-spread drama-thriller “Eileen” appears just like the type of film one needs to luxuriate in. Indeed, the masterful “Lady Macbeth” director’s interval piece guarantees to be the cinematic equal of a lavish fur coat at first look, so inviting in its smoky mahogany interiors and mutedly heat shade palette that it feels simple to slide into, no questions requested.
READ MORE: 25 Most Anticipated Films At The Sundance Film Festival
Which is why it seems like a tragedy when “Eileen” doesn’t stay as much as the preliminary contract it attracts up with its viewers. It’s a deal that entails a female coming-of-age story, a mysterious femme fatale she is intellectually and sexually enthralled by, and a left-field twist that sends the 2 off to hazard’s approach unexpectedly, all in opposition to the backdrop of the icy New England of the 60s. Based on the novel by Ottessa Moshfegh, the script (by Moshfegh and Luke Goebel, additionally collaborators on the latest “Causeway”) does have all these promising components, to be clear. But it connects the dots between them so hurriedly that “Eileen” leaves one questioning whether or not there was speculated to be a further 20 minutes to the film someplace that somebody by accident deleted.
Considering that “Eileen” is a latest Sundance premiere, this statement may appear odd and unusual, with the pageant normally having the other downside by means of cluttered films begging to be shortened all the way down to a leaner minimize. But the spareness of the noir-adjacent “Eileen” more and more seems like a bug after its chief feminine characters meet in essentially the most uncommon of locations — a boys-only jail in Massachusetts — and embark on a journey that carefully resembles “Carol” in feeling and elegance, filled with glances, unintentional touches and pregnant silences that recommend the arrival of a romance quickly. Who wouldn’t need these ladies to be the heroes of a film that patiently propels them to 1 one other, by means of intimacy, rigidity and resolutions that really feel natural?
“Eileen” leaves quite a bit to be desired in that division, however not less than it strikes attractively for some time, aided significantly by Ari Wegner‘s typically luscious cinematography. We get introduced to the 24-year-old titular character first, a lowly secretary in the aforesaid prison, portrayed by the wonderful Thomasin McKenzie with a deceptively childlike and gradually ripening mystique, the kind she recently mastered in “Last Night in Soho.” Dealing with her often drunk, neighborhood nuisance ex-cop father (Shea Whigham) that she still lives with on the one side and bored by her mind-numbing job on the other, Eileen spends her days having vivid sexual fantasies, spying on happy couples’ make-out classes and indulging in sweets, maybe to brighten up her boring days a contact.
It all adjustments for the plainly dressed younger lady when the completely glamorous Rebecca (a charming Anne Hathaway) arrives to the establishment as workers psychologist. With a radiantly sculpted, Marilyn-esque blonde hairdo, form-hugging pencil skirt-suits that outline her alluring stroll (Hathaway actually works Olga Mills’ lustrous costume designs) and a cigarette completely hooked up between her fingers, Rebecca instantly grabs the smitten Eileen’s consideration, with the 2 typically locking glances. It doesn’t take lengthy for the newcomer to ask this quiet, unusual younger lady out and assist her come out of her shell. Elsewhere, we study concerning the arrival of a troubled younger man to the jail, serving time after killing his father, questioning how he and his mom (a scene-stealing Marin Ireland) will ultimately declare a slice of the overarching narrative.
The scenes by which Eileen and Rebecca begin to get to know each other really feel merely as fantastic as sips of positive whisky, leaving a seductive burn in a single’s throat. But they’re additionally painfully restricted — actually, there is just one sequence that exhibits them on an actual outing when the duo go to a bar and freely dance to The Exciters’ “Tell Him” in entrance of prying male appears. After this tease, Rebecca inexplicably disappears from the story for an pointless period of time, leaving Eileen along with her annoyingly deadpan co-workers and sometimes depressing dad. We do get to know the younger lady slightly higher in these segments, glancing into her soul a bit extra carefully whereas she spends time within the firm of her messy father, whom she typically fantasizes harming. (A request: might we retire the clichéd scenes the place a quiet individual imagines hurt and homicide she doesn’t undergo with, however the viewers sees anyway?) But we additionally do miss Rebecca awfully throughout this time, in addition to the self-confident, glamorous individual Eileen slowly grows into when she’s along with her.
It seems like a little bit of mischief when Rebecca reemerges and invitations Eileen to her place for Christmas eve, with the younger girl preparing for the date with a high-school lady’s pleasure and butterflies in her abdomen. And it’s an entire shock when Rebecca reveals the actual purpose she’s invited Eileen, one which crosses all of the skilled and authorized boundaries she’s supposed to ascertain at work.
It’s not value spoiling this twist, considerably unmerited and random contemplating that we barely see Rebecca at work and grasp sufficient of her skilled character — once more, a deficit of the film. Similarly, it doesn’t appear all too credible when Eileen decides to assist her crush who’s discovered herself in an sudden prison pickle. Because we don’t see them collectively sufficient, their newfound accord feels unearned, regardless of the leads’ utmost dedication. Which is to say the ending of the film sadly fizzles. Through one other delicate twist, the purpose it makes is evident: Eileen is lastly her personal individual in physique and thoughts, now not in want of anybody’s validation. If solely “Eileen” took the scenic path to that vacation spot, as an alternative of leaping off a cliff to get there. [B-]
Follow together with all our protection of the 2023 Sundance Film Festival