TORONTO – A radio rightsholder’s plan to return to pandemic-style distant protection of Toronto Blue Jays street video games is “very short-sighted in terms of the impact it’s going to have,” a sports activities advertising skilled mentioned.
Richard Powers, a professor on the University of Toronto’s Rotman School of Management, mentioned with the sports activities world basically again to regular, Sportsnet’s determination might find yourself costing the group followers.
“To keep this going, the only way you can justify it is as a cost-saving measure,” he mentioned. “My take is it doesn’t make any sense at all because it erodes the fan experience.
“It’s difficult on radio already. It just erodes it further by doing something like this.”
COVID-19 issues and journey restrictions meant distant broadcasting was the norm within the early days of the pandemic. The distinction was usually noticeable, but it surely was typically accepted given the bizarre circumstances.
Almost all big-league baseball radio crews have resumed common journey. In the NHL and NBA, a handful of markets proceed to make use of distant radio protection.
Sportsnet’s broadcasting plans for the Blue Jays’ 2023 season have been unveiled this month in a information launch. There will likely be full on-site tv protection for all 162 video games, however radio employees will solely be within the ballpark for the 81 dwelling video games.
“It’s a shame for a team that services (an entire country) — really, the largest market in Major League Baseball — to not invest in a top-notch broadcast,” mentioned sports activities media analyst Adam Seaborn, head of partnerships at Toronto-based media firm Playmaker Capital.
Calling a sport off a display screen could be difficult since hosts are on the mercy of the digital camera. They merely can’t get a whole image from the sector of play regardless of what number of feeds can be found.
Related Videos
“As a colleague of mine likes to say, it’s like teaching swimming through correspondence,” Powers mentioned. “You’re not there.”
The street radio determination was panned by many group supporters on social media. Longtime Blue Jays radio voice Jerry Howarth mentioned he was “very disappointed” within the community’s determination.
“You don’t get any kind of picture of what’s happening regarding a ripple effect of a play, a call, emotions, people that are involved in the call one way or another, because you’re not there,” Howarth mentioned.
“You can’t see that. So you can’t fully appreciate what is happening at that very moment.”
The group’s present radio voice, Ben Wagner, has been calling video games since 2018.
His name is heard on 14 Sportsnet Radio Network associates, together with the flagship Fan590 all-sports station. Audio streaming can also be accessible on the Sportsnet web site and app.
Wagner is on website for Grapefruit League pre-season protection in Florida. When the Blue Jays’ common season begins March 30 at St. Louis, he’ll begin calling street video games off screens from Toronto.
“For a few extra dollars to send (a) broadcaster on the road for the good that it has been in baseball for (many) years, its importance to the game and to the audience, I don’t get it,” Howarth mentioned.
Sportsnet is a part of Rogers Sports & Media, a subsidiary of Rogers Communications Inc. The Toronto-based telecom large additionally owns the Blue Jays and Rogers Centre.
Earlier this month, Rogers reported a fourth-quarter revenue of $508 million. The firm continues to be ready for ultimate approvals on its $26-billion acquisition of Shaw Communications Inc.
A Sportsnet spokesman declined additional touch upon radio protection plans. Interview requests with community brass have been declined.
“It’s a mindset that is really trying to keep their resources on the big fish in their (broadcasting) pond, which is TV,” mentioned Mike Naraine, an assistant professor of sports activities administration at Brock University. “That’s what they know and that’s what they love.”
Howarth, who retired in 2018, labored with radio companions over his profession. Wagner, in the meantime, is basically a one-man present with occasional contributors and analysts.
“I think having the radio team on the road for the games is a very easy way to signal to your fans that we value your time, we value your money, we want you to buy a jersey and buy a hat,” Seaborn mentioned. “We value your fandom.
“An easy brand-building exercise and they could have spun it into a really good story.”
Specifics on journey prices weren’t accessible, however radio journey is usually cheap.
Most radio broadcasters can journey on the group constitution. That leaves lodge, per diem and the expense of an audio producer/technician — usually a contract cost in every market — as the principle prices.
“To me the cost of putting (a) baseball broadcaster on the road is insignificant compared to what you get in return for your audience,” Howarth mentioned in a latest interview.
Longtime Toronto broadcaster Mark Hebscher commonly lined the Blue Jays within the group’s early days, usually making the journey to Dunedin, Fla., for spring coaching.
He famous the significance of the press field view for a medium like radio, the place particulars of the scene, gamers, and emotion throughout the stadium can captivate a listener.
“You don’t get that if you’re watching it on a monitor,” he mentioned in a latest interview. “It really does a disservice because there is nothing better than a radio broadcast of a game where they’re actually there.
“They can describe to you what it feels like and what the atmosphere is like at the game. There’s no way you can portray it — you can try — but you can’t portray that if you’re not sitting at the game.”
Wagner referred to as street video games remotely final season earlier than resuming common journey for a lot of the second half of the marketing campaign.
“They’re spending $300 million renovating the ballpark and they’re spending how many millions of dollars on a relief pitcher,” Seaborn mentioned. “For a (small) fraction of that, you can have the radio person on the road.
“If the quality of broadcast is improved even five or 10 per cent, it seems worth it.”
This report by The Canadian Press was first printed Feb. 23, 2023.
Follow @GregoryStrongCP on Twitter.